What more could you ask for: games, live sports TV featuring NFL Package, live entertainment, and a casual atmosphere with great food to boot. If you’re not having fun we’re going to make you walk the plank. Whether it’s that big game or your favorite band, or just suds at the bar, relax in ourSports Bar with a few (or more) of your friends.
Starters and Sharables
Fried to perfection and accompanied by our house made honey jalapeno sauce.
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail13.50
Oversized tiger shrimp served with a lemon wedge and cocktail sauce.
This house special has become one of the area’s best known treasures! We have tried them all over the world and these have proven the best.Our signature blend of spinach, bacon, oysters and a few other items we keep to ourselves. Served 6 per order. Allow additional time.
Add chicken $3
The classic version but Matey’s sized. Cheese, onion and tomato is standard form.
Shrimp and Crab Extremers9.99
An amazing shrimp and crab popper with a mild jalapeno kick.
Served warm with our signature cheese dipping sauce.
Lightly seasoned and perfectly fried. Served with marinara sauce.
Basket of Onion Rings6.99
Basket of Fries5.99
Locally sourced when available, fresh vine ripened tomatoes with balsamic, basil, fresh mozzarella cheese and prosciutto atop a freshly prepared crostini.
Sub chicken $3
Freshly made tortilla chips topped with our seasoned ground beef, cheese, lettuce, tomato, olives, onions and jalapenos.Drizzled with sour cream and cilantro pesto and served with a side of salsa.
Add cheese dipping sauce $1
Always a favorite, warm breadsticks stuffed with mozzarella cheese. Served with marinara sauce.
Deep Fried pickles7.99
Crunchy, with that salt and vinegar combo we all love so much. Served with ranch.
Matey’s Sampler Platter15.99
A little bit of all the favorites: Chicken Wings, Onion Rings, Extremers, Deep Fried Pickles and cheese sticks. No substitutions please
Featuring two jumbo lump crab and our signature blend of spices, pan seared and topped with our zesty Louis sauce
Jumbo Chicken Wings or Boneless Wings12.99
Extra sauces 50¢
1lb. per order. These fresh oversized wings are a true star. Crispy and served with your choice of sauce. Served with blue cheese or ranch.
Choose your sauce: Garlic Parmesan, Mango Habanero, Citrus Chipotle, Buffalo, Red Chili, Kickin Bourbon, Sweet Teriyaki, Honey Hot Wing, Golden BBQ, HOT, Korean BBQ, Mild, Medium, Dry Rub, Sweet BBQ
Oversized taco bowl made to order then filled with mixed greens and topped with our seasoned ground beef, olives, tomatoes, onions and shredded cheese. Served with sour cream and tangy salsa.
For the seafood lover in everyone. Fresh greens topped with a hearty portion of our chilled shrimp and crab. Also topped with tomato, cucumber, pepperoncini and croutons.
Half Wedge Salad4.99
Sirloin Steak Salad12.99
A nice beefy steak atop fresh crisp greens, tomatoes, onion, cucumbers, and more plus smoked blue cheese crumbles
ALMOST WORLD FAMOUS CAJUN CHOWDER
Bowl $4.99 / Cup $3.99
FRESH SOUP OF THE DAY
Bowl $3.99 / Cup $2.99
Delicious & Simple
Fish and Chips11.99
The Famous Matey Burger9.99
½ lb fresh ground beef burger, with American cheese.
A must try! 1/2lb burger with our signature peppercorn cream sauce, rich gouda cheese and crispy bacon.
Blue Cheese Burger12.99
Not on top, but inside! Our ½ burger stuffed with creamy blue cheese.
Mushroom Swiss Burger10.99
Can’t miss with sautéed mushroom and swiss cheese.
Caramelized onions & melted swiss cheese, served on toasted rye bread.
Build Your Own Burger $8.99
You choose the toppings – $1.00 each
Caramelized Mushrooms & onions
OUR SIGNATURE SANDWICHES
THE FIRST MATE11.99
Slow roasted prime rib, shaved very thin, on a Kaiser roll, with au jus or our homemade horseradish sauce.
Fire Down Below9.99
Grilled, smoked chicken breast covered in pepper jack cheese, sizzling bacon and jalapeno ranch dressing, all on a toasted bun.
Ultimate Chicken Sandwich8.99
Grilled, crispy or buffalo style. Hand trimmed, house marinated chicken breast on our over sized brioche bun.
Add bacon or cheese $1 each
Matey’s Soon to be Famous Steak Sandwich13.49
Tender, marinated sirloin steak topped with caramelized onions and mushrooms, with our creamy peppercorn sauce, all on our crusty French baguette. Add swiss or mozz cheese for just $1 more!
Prime Philly Cheese steak12.99
Shaved Prime Rib takes this classic up more than one notch! Topped with mushrooms, onions, peppers, and of course, lots of cheese
Drunken Fish Tacos12.99
Is the fish drunk or the cook? Beer battered cod cradled in white corn tortillas, topped with shredded cabbage, cheddar cheese and our Louis sauce.
Our take on a Cuban sandwich, fresh French baguette piled with our house marinated pork tenderloin, thick sliced ham, swiss cheese, coleslaw, pickles
and our spicy mustard. Pressed to get a perfect crunch with each bite.
Crab Cake Sandwich11.99
Our chef’s famous recipe makes this unique sandwich a local favorite, topped with his zesty Louis sauce.
Fish SandwichCod 10.99 / Lake Perch 13.99
Lots of choices here for you – cod or lake perch?
Grilled or hand battered deep fried? Let us make it just for you!
A Chicago tradition perfected here, thinly shaved slow-roasted beef with spicy giardinera on a French baguette
(starting at 5 pm – may be available earlier upon request) Includes your choice of potato (baked, mashed or our signature au gratin) & chef’s vegetable. Add soup, side salad or ½ wedge salad for just $2.99 • Full entrée menu available in Chart Room.
Beer Battered Lake Perch17.99
Piled high, a local favorite.
12 oz House trimmed and cut Angus ribeye beef, with our own steak seasoning blend and grilled to your desired temperature.
8 oz Wet aged for maximum tenderness and flavor, hand cut and house seasoned. A delicious and beefy flavored steak.
Your choice of chicken breast or shrimp tossed with artichokes, olives, tomatoes, basil, garlic and olive oil a top a bed of fettucini noodles, with garlic bread (no starch option)
(Friday & Saturdays starting at 5 pm) House special, seasoned with our chef’s unique blend of herbs and spices, slow roasted and cut to order. Served until we run out!
Petite cut 10 oz $20.99 / King Cut 16 oz $26.99
Sesame coated on a bed of crispy Asian slaw
Buffalo Chicken Wrap9.99
Our crunchy boneless wings coated in buffalo sauce, tossed with blue cheese and crisp greens, all wrapped up
A summertime favorite! With creamy fresh mozzarella, basil leaves, diced vine-ripe tomatoes and balsamic glaze
Chicken Caesar Wrap9.99
Grilled chicken, fresh greens, tomatoes, shredded parmesan and Caesar dressing
Seared Tuna Salad12.99
Sesame coated tuna cooked to medium rare, served on crunchy greens with Asian dressing
Blue Point Oysters
3 for 6.99 6 for 12.99
3 for 5.99 6 for 11.99
Delicious, light and flaky grouper pan fried, topped with our tartar sauce, lettuce and tomato, includes fries