Everyday: 11am – 1am
Appetizers & Shareable
Oyster Rockefeller Back Again Tour
Back by popular demand! This long time Matey's signature is back for a limited time. You've tried them other places, now try the best. Baked on the half shell with our signature spinach Parmesan cream sauce, bacon, breadcrumbs
Half Order (6) 17.99
Full Order (12) 28.99
YO HO FRIED GREEN TOMATOES16.95
Yes indeed friends, these are house made!
Soaked overnight, breaded with our kicked up
cornmeal special blend and deep fried to order.
Accompanied with a trio of dipping sauces to
keep you coming back for more of this classic
CRABBY PATTIES24.95
You don’t have to live under the sea to recognize
this appetizer will fill you up but not because of
all the fillers. Just enough bread crumb to bind
these crab cakes made with super jumbo lump
crab, pan seared & presented over a bed of
mixed greens with pineapple & jalapeno salsa,
and lemon dill.
SHIPYARD PRETZEL & KICKED UP CHEESE12.95
Say Cheese! Two freshly baked soft pretzels
accompanied by our signature tequila con queso
cheese sauce (don’t worry, we aren’t trying to
get your kids drunk, it’s just a kiss of tequila for
that smoky kicker you’re going to love)
Signature Shrimp Cocktail15.99
Our version just tastes better! Oversized shrimp, brined with a hint of old bay and pickling seasoning, served chilled with our zesty cocktail sauce
ANCHORS AWAY NACHOS OR TATCHOS
Classic Nachos
Taco meat, our house queso,
t
omato, green onion, jalapeno, verde crema,
piled high atop a bed of tortilla chips
........
17.95
Substitute chicken
......................................
19.95
Tater Totchos
Our house queso, tomato, green
onion, jalapeno, verde crema, and bacon crumble
on a base of perfectly crisp tater tots
........
14.95
Substitute taco meat
...................................
17.95
Substitute chicken
......................................
19.95
DEEP FRIED PICKLES10.99
Seven of our famous deep fried pickle spears
served with house made jalapeno ranch
BAM-BAM SHRIMP14.95
Hand battered and deep fried until GBD (golden,
brown and DELICIOUS), served with Matey’s
house made bam bam sauce (mild kick for those
of you afraid of some heat). Simple but delicious.
Sweet Chili Pineapple12.99
A Matey's original! You do not want to miss the opportunity to try this unique app featuring thick cut pineapple spears, grilled to add that smokey sweetness and then glazed with our Thai Chili sauce.Accompanied by micro greens and crispy prosciutto to add a savory component
SCALLYWAG SIGNATURE JUMBO SCALLOPS21.95
A truly elevated appetizer - don’t miss out.
Three large U-10 scallops (fresh when available)
perfectly seared and plated on top of our
amazing and refreshing citrus bur blanc and
topped with pineapple & jalapeno salsa.
BUCCANEER BACON MAC N’ CHEESE BITES15.95
Bacon makes everything better! Gooey Gouda
mac and cheese, layered with bacon, breaded
and fried to perfection. Served with your choice
of ranch or buffalo ranch
Not The Same Old Crispy Calamari14.99
Hand cut and lightly battered in house, crispy fried rings and tentacles, pickled Fresno peppers, with our jalapeño honey dipping sauce. (Cocktail sauce available)
Mozzarella Sticks8.99
Tossed in freshly grated parmesan after perfectly fried, just to be a little extra! Served with marinara sauce
Chicken Fingers11.99
Basket of Fries or Onion Rings7.49
Chips and Salsa6.99
Traditional and salsa verde - now made IN HOUSE!
Specialty Flatbreads
CALIFORNIA CHICKEN16.95
Grilled chicken bacon, red onion, pepper jack,
avocado, green onion, Chipotle ranch.
CAPRESE16.95
Basil pesto
base, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes,arugula, balsamic drizzle
BBQ CHICKEN16.95
Grilled chicken, cheese
blend, red and green
onion choice of wing sauce
TACO16.95
We don’t do taco Tuesday but we do
taco pizza!!!
Creamy taco sauce base, taco meat, lettuce,
Tomato, sour cream drizzle to finish
Baskets
ALL BASKETS ARE SERVED WITH FRIES
COCONUT SHRIMP17.99
Served with sweet & sour sauce or cocktail sauce
CHICKEN TENDERS14.99
YOUR CHOICE OF RANCH, BBQ OR HONEY MUSTARD FOR DIPPING
BREADED SHRIMP16.99
BREADED AND FRIED WITH COCKTAIL SAUCE
Mateys Cheese ~ N ~ Mac
That's right, we add the Mac to the Cheese. Aged bubbling white cheddar adhered to every spiral on those rotini noodles topped with breadcrumbs to provide some crunch14.99
Add ons: Grilled Chicken $5, Crispy Chicken $5,
Shrimp $7, Salmon $12, Veggie (portobello and
roasted tomato) $5
Matey's Soon To Be Famous Wings
Traditional (Bone-In) or boneless. 24-hour brine with our top-secret spice blend makes these wings tender and juicy every time. The then perfectly crispy fried wings are hand-tossed in your favorite sauce. You’ll think we should open our own wing joint.
Snack portion9.99
varies by size, approximately 6
Full portion16.99
varies by size, approximately 12
Celery & Carrots1.00
Homemade Signature sauce
Honey BBQ, Thai Chili, Mild, Spicy Garlic, Matey's Nuclear
HANDHELDS
Handhelds are served with chips. Substitute fries or onion rings 2.99
New Island Chicken Wrap15.99
You’ll feel like you’re on permanent vacation
with this Mediterranean flavor explosion.
Grilled chicken, feta cheese, Kalamata olives,
tomato, red onion, lemon herb vinaigrette
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap14.99
Crisp greens, tomato, chunks of grilled chicken
with our Caesar dressing.
Bring it Back Buffalo Chicken Wrap13.95
You asked, so its back. Crispy or grilled
chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, blue cheese or
ranch, choice of wing sauce
THE FIRST MATE15.99
Shaved prime rib served on a brioche bun with
au jus and homemade horsey sauce
Add cheese $1
THE KEY WESTER BLACKENED GROUPER SANDWICH17.99
Blackened grouper, lettuce, tomato, onion,
old bay tartar, signature hoagie bun
SON OF A BISCUIT EATER SOFT SHELL CRAB SANDWICH18.95
ou won’t find this anywhere else locally.
Premium soft shell crab, lightly battered and
deep fried. Accompanied by arugula, red onion
and topped with lemon aioli
Fire Down Below13.99
Grilled chicken breast sandwich topped with
pepper jack cheese, bacon, lettuce, onion
tomato, jalapeno ranch sauce.
MAN-O-WAR CHICKEN Sandwich16.95
Not all things HOT need to blow out your taste
buds. Perfect bland of flavor and deep heat.
Take our full size chicken breast, grilled or
fried, tossed in our nuclear sauce, pepper jack
cheese, jalapeno ranch and topped with our
pineapple&jalapeno slaw to cool you down a bit.
It’s a flavor bomb! (Substitute any of our wing
sauces for a milder version)
GO COASTAL Chicken Sandwich16.95
Crispy or grilled, bacon, avocado, provolone
cheese, Chipolte ranch.
DRUNKEN FISH TACOS16.95
That’s right, they are BACK! Is the fish drunk
or our cooks – please let us know!? Haha!!!
Beer batter hand dipped cod tenderloins,
pineapple jalapeno slaw, verde crema
TWISTED AHI TUNA TACOS19.95
Tempura battered ahi tuna chunks, carrot
and jicama slaw, pickled ginger, sesame
seeds, wasabi aioli
Burgers
To accommodate the popularity of burgers, all burgers are served “pink” or “no pink” Served with chips, mayo, and pickles on our signature rolls made specifically to hold these monster burgers. Substitute fries or onion rings $2.99
Make any burger deluxe (lettuce, tomato & onion)………… $2
Cheeses: American, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Swiss, Blue Cheese
The Famous Matey Burger16.99
1/2lb. 100% Angus beef signature patty with your choice of cheese
Add egg: 2.00 | Add bacon: 2.00
Impossible Burger15.99
We couldn't believe it wasn't beef either. If meat isn't your thing or you're in the mood to mix things up try this amazing plant based patty with your choice of cheese
The Green Stuff
GREEK SALAD12.95
Mixed greens, peppercionni, kalamata olives,
feta cheese, cucumber, lemon herb vinaigrette
AHOY AHI TUNA SALAD24.95
Seared ahi tuna, mixed greens, carrots and
jicama, red pepper, red onion, sesame ginger
vinaigrette.
CROW’S NEST CAPRESE14.95
Arugula, tomato, fresh mozzerella, balsamic
vinegar and finished with a balsamic glaze
drizzle. Add thin sliced Procuitto for $6.95
HAIL CAESAR12.95
Classic Caesar, crisp romaine, croutons, shaved
aged Parmesan, house made Caesar dressing
Add ons: Grilled Chicken $5, Crispy Chicken $5,
Shrimp $7, Salmon $12
The main Attraction
SURFSIDE SALMON21.99
Pan
seared Atlantic salmon, lemon caper cream sauce, blistered
cherry tomato, mashed potatoes
and chef's vegetable
COME BACK AGAIN GROUPER23.99
We’ll be seeing you soon once you try this updated classic.Panseared grouper, cilantro lime basmatirice, coconut ginger curry,blistered cherry tomato,and chef's vegetable
14 OZ CERTIFIED ANGUS BEEF RIBEYE29.95
You don’t have to overpay for a great steak. Handcut, grilled to temp,
served with choice of potato and chef’s vegetable
PAN SEARED CHICKEN IN WHITE WINE BUTTER SAUCE21.95
Served over bed of linguini
CARBONARA17.95
Creamy carbonara enhanced with our aged shaved Parmesan,
prosciutto and peas, then tossed with linguini noodles and pan
finished for the flavors to meld.
Add ons: Grilled Chicken $5, Crispy Chicken $5, Shrimp $7, Salmon $12
Arrrrr Risottos
WHISTLE BLOWER WHITE CHEDDAR18.95
Slow cooked to a perfect al dente with chicken broth, cream and
thickened with a 10 year aged white cheddar. A handful of peas
mixed in for a pop of flavor.
MUTINY MUSHROOM17.95
So good your taste buds will revolt when you stop eating. Slow cooked
to a perfect al dente with beef broth to fortify that meaty mushroom flavor.
Our mushrooms are marinated and cooked crispy, then rehydrated to give
you a unique taste and texture. You won’t believe the flavor
SEADOG SHORTRIB36.95
Marinated and slow braised short rib signature cut just for us, served over
mushroom risotto and a drizzle chimichurri to brighten everything up. You
might think you’ve had short ribs but you’ll think differently after trying these.
SCALLYWAG SCALLOPS34.95
Perfectly pan seared jumbo U-10 scallops served over our white cheddar
risotto, peas, citrus bur blanc for a flavor profile that will leave you wanting
more.(substitute shrimp for the same price)