Monday -Thursday : 11 AM 1 AM
Friday -Sunday : 11 AM 3 AM
Appetizers & Shareable
Oyster Rockefeller Back Again Tour
Back by popular demand! This long time Matey's signature is back for a limited time. You've tried them other places, now try the best. Baked on the half shell with our signature spinach Parmesan cream sauce, bacon, breadcrumbs
Half Order (6) 17.99
Full Order (12) 28.99
Signature Shrimp Cocktail15.99
Our version just tastes better! Oversized shrimp, brined with a hint of old bay and pickling seasoning, served chilled with our zesty cocktail sauce
Sweet Chili Pineapple12.99
A Matey's original! You do not want to miss the opportunity to try this unique app featuring thick cut pineapple spears, grilled to add that smokey sweetness and then glazed with our Thai Chili sauce.Accompanied by micro greens and crispy prosciutto to add a savory component
Not The Same Old Crispy Calamari14.99
Hand cut and lightly battered in house, crispy fried rings and tentacles, pickled Fresno peppers, with our jalapeño honey dipping sauce. (Cocktail sauce available)
Off The Boat Ahi Tuna Ceviche14.99
So fresh you'll feel like it was caught this morning. Sushi-grade yellow fin tuna, tomato, jalapeño, cilantro, and red onion complete this palate pleaser. Served with tortilla chips
Mozzarella Sticks8.99
Tossed in freshly grated parmesan after perfectly fried, just to be a little extra! Served with marinara sauce
Chicken Fingers11.99
Basket of Fries or Onion Rings7.49
Chips and Salsa6.99
Traditional and salsa verde - now made IN HOUSE!
Matey's Soon To Be Famous Wings
Traditional (Bone-In) or boneless. 24-hour brine with our top-secret spice blend makes these wings tender and juicy every time. The then perfectly crispy fried wings are hand-tossed in your favorite sauce. You’ll think we should open our own wing joint.
Snack portion9.99
varies by size, approximately 6
Full portion16.99
varies by size, approximately 12
Celery & Carrots1.00
Homemade Signature sauce
Honey BBQ, Thai Chili, Mild, Spicy Garlic, Matey's Nuclear
Burgers
To accommodate the popularity of burgers, all burgers are served “pink” or “no pink” Served with chips, mayo, and pickles on our signature rolls made specifically to hold these monster burgers. Substitute fries or onion rings $2.99
Make any burger deluxe (lettuce, tomato & onion)………… $2
Cheeses: American, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Swiss, Blue Cheese
The Famous Matey Burger16.99
1/2lb. 100% Angus beef signature patty with your choice of cheese
Add egg: 2.00 | Add bacon: 2.00
Impossible Burger
We couldn't believe it wasn't beef either. If meat isn't your thing or you're in the mood to mix things up try this amazing plant based patty with your choice of cheese
Flatbreads
California Chicken Flatbread14.99
California might be full of weirdos but this inspired flatbread hits the spot. Grilled chicken breast, bacon, red onion, pepper jack, avocado, green onion, Chipotle ranch
Margherita Flatbread11.99
This classic is a don’t miss. Marinara base sauce, thinly sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and a dusting of basil
Entreés
Yes, the entrees are back! Missed by so many, these retro favorites have been remixed by our talented new chefs.
Surfside Salmon21.99
Pan seared Atlantic Salmon, lemon caper cream sauce, blistered cherry tomato, asparagus, mashed potatoes
Come Back Again Grouper23.99
We'll be seeing you again once you try this updated classic. Pan seared grouper, cilantro lime basmati rice, coconut ginger curry, blistered cherry tomato, asparagus
Sizzlin' Skirt Steak29. 99
Marinated and grilled, roasted red pepper chimichurri, grilled zucchini and squash, mashed potatoes
Mateys Cheese ~ N ~ Mac
That’s right, we add the Mac to the Cheese. Aged bubbling white cheddar adhered to every spiral on those rotini noodles topped with breadcrumbs to provide some crunch
That's right, we add the Mac to the Cheese. Aged bubbling white cheddar adhered to every spiral on those rotini noodles topped with breadcrumbs to provide some crunch14.99
Add ons: Grilled Chicken $5, fried chicken $5, Skirt steak $14, Shrimp $7, Salmon $12, Veggie (portobello and roasted tomato) $5
Baskets
ALL BASKETS ARE SERVED WITH FRIES
COCONUT SHRIMP17.99
Served with sweet & sour sauce or cocktail sauce
CHICKEN TENDERS14.99
YOUR CHOICE OF RANCH, BBQ OR HONEY MUSTARD FOR DIPPING
BREADED SHRIMP16.99
BREADED AND FRIED WITH COCKTAIL SAUCE
Salads
Ahoy Iceberg Wedge12.99
Everyone has one, but our relaxed lakeside atmosphere and charming staff make everything taste better. Iceberg wedge, bacon, cherry tomato, blue cheese crumble and ranch dressing
Pineapple & Goat Cheese Salad15.99
You don't have to visit the Conch Republic to experience this local delight! Romaine and spring mix, goat cheese, sautéed pineapple, crispy prosciutto, toasted pine nuts tossed with a light honey Dijon vinaigrette. One of our island favorites.
HANDHELDS
All sandwiches include chips and a pickle. Add slaw – $ 0.99
Side salad- 2.99 | Sub fries – 1.99
MATEY'S BURGER8.99
1/2lb. of beef served deluxe with American cheese
CRABCAKE SANDWICH11.99
Chef Paul famous recipe, topped with homemade crab Louie sauce
FIRST MATE11.99
super thin shaved prime rib on a Kaiser with au jus or horseradish
GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH -8.99
served with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo